Dry January – Is It Worth It?

Written by on 1 January 2013 in Seasonal - 8 Comments

(Photo: {a href=”http://www.flickr.com/photos/mikeshaheenphotography/”}Mike Shaheen{/a})

It’s that time of year again when some people decide to take a month off from drinking alcohol. But is there any point?

The short answer is maybe. The long answer takes six hours and involves me playing an accordion. The medium-length answer is below.

What is Dry January?

Dry January is an annual practice whereby people lay off drinking alcohol for the whole month of January. Well, not quite the whole month – many are realistic enough to set January 2nd as the start date. Some in Australia, meanwhile, simply wait for Ocsober.

We seem to be in the epoch of the month-long charity initiatives. There’s the well-known Movember, the lesser known Decembeard and Frocktober. And Dry January itself has a potential fund-raising element, it being an Alcohol Concern initiative.

As to whether Dry January is worth it, this really all depends on what your motivations are.

Liver detox

If your intention is to detox your liver, then the British Liver Trust is keen to point out that this is daft.

According to Consultant Hepatologist Dr Mark Wright (from a British Liver Trust press release in 2012): “Detoxing for just a month in January is medically futile. It can lead to a false sense of security and feeds the idea that you can abuse your liver as much as you like and then sort everything else with a quick fix.”

“It makes about as much sense as maxing out your credit cards and overdraft all year, then thinking you can fix it by just eating toast in January. The figures just don’t stack up.”

But then, the very term ‘detox’ should set alarm bells ringing in its own right, according to skeptics.

Benefits of not drinking

Alcohol affects more than just your liver. So, stopping drinking for a while obviously brings with it certain benefits. If you want to do any of the following, you’re in luck:

  • Save money
  • Lose weight
  • Discover the crazy and exotic world of ‘life without hangovers’
  • Pay off your sleep debt

And there are various other positives besides.

But the benefits of not drinking take time, so don’t wake up on January 3rd saying “WHY DON’T I FEEL SUPERHUMAN YET?” Indeed, things might get worse before they get better.

As the UK’s National Health Service points out: “Alcohol withdrawal symptoms can range from not sleeping, agitation, anxiety, sweating and tremors, right through to vomiting, diarrhoea, hallucinations and seizures”

And that comes with an extra warning: “If your body has become dependent on booze, stopping drinking overnight can be life-threatening”.

So if you’re going to make any significant changes to your alcohol intake, you should strongly consider discussing it with your GP/physician.



(Photo: {a href=”http://www.flickr.com/photos/quinnanya/”}quinn.anya{/a})


Learn about your relationship with alcohol

One of the best reasons to give up is more difficult to measure statistically – it can make you question your relationship with alcohol.

When I stopped drinking back in 2006, I couldn’t get over just how intrinsic it had been to my life. I suddenly realised that I associated it with pretty much every social occasion I engaged in. Even lying down in the gutter with vomit on my shirt suddenly seemed a little strange with no alcohol in my system. Though it’s always nice to reminisce, obviously.

This, in my opinion, is why it’s worth going about it the right way. I’ve heard people say that Dry January is easy – they just stay in the whole time. But this will also likely limit what you can learn. Aside from the fact that it’s probably cheating.

If you really want to learn something then you should really be trying to doing all the same things you usually do: What is it like to be in the pub without a beer in your hand? What internal protests do you hear yourself making? Listen to others, too – if people are saying things like “It’s really funny to hear you talking coherently!” then there might be a message in there for you.

Interpersonal relationships and alcohol

Which brings me onto the next point: the effect on others.

If you’re a heavy drinker, taking a month off might make a pleasant change for the people around you. I say ‘might’, because the reality of you whinging constantly for over four weeks might not be all that great after all.

“The strangest thing about the experience was the amount people who made me feel like I was expected to justify my choice, or tried to bully me into having a drink.” – Janis Callister

Not that those around you will always be happy with your choice. As Janis Callister, regular contributor here, notes of  her own first foray into Dry January: “The strangest thing about the experience was the amount people who made me feel like I was expected to justify my choice, or tried to bully me into having a drink.”

From a completely selfish point of view, I love it when other people do Dry January. Experience tells me that they’re more able to relate to my own situation (I don’t generally drink alcohol). Unless like Sickboy in Trainspotting they’ve given something up just to undermine the achievements of others that have done the same.

Long-term approach

Whether or not doing Dry January translates to a long-term change is open to speculation – I’m not aware of any figures to support any kind of general trend.

Whilst in principle you might have an improved idea, in practice you might end up drinking more – that false sense of security that Dr. Mark Wright spoke about.

My friend Andrea recounts: “I don’t think there was a long term change, I went back to drinking but it was definitely a positive experience and made me think about my alcohol consumption.”

Janis, meanwhile, says: “I’m now a little more used to not drinking, so will offer to drive where I can for family things. I also know which non alcoholic drinks I like, and that you can drink nice drinks that don’t make you feel sickly.”

If you really want to make a long-term difference to your wellbeing, it might be better to moderate your drinking on a regular basis rather having than an annual purge. This is an idea promoted by the British Liver Trust’s Love Your Liver campaign.

Chief Executive of the British Liver Trust, Andrew Langford, says: “You’re better off making a resolution to take a few days off alcohol a week throughout the entire year than remaining abstinent for January only.”

How you’d actually go about that is a whole other article in itself.

EDIT: Here’s a good web-based app to help you to do exactly that, showing you the money and calories you’ve saved by cutting back: MyDrinkaware

What do you think of Dry January? Have you ever tried? Did you meet with success of failure? Was it a worthwhile exercise or simply a waste of good drinking time?

8 Comments on "Dry January – Is It Worth It?"

  1. Christina Howker-Fullard 1 January 2013 at 9:17 pm · Reply

    Interesting topic. I’ve had a ‘just about dry’ year and a half now due to planning a baby, carrying one and then feeding it. One thing I’ve noticed is how many hangover statuses get posted on facebook (and how dull that is). Also, that I don’t miss hangovers and after having some health issues since my boy was born, I don’t intend to drink to the point of getting a hangover ever again. It’s been disappointing and unpleasant being ill through no fault of my own, so I’m damn sure I’ll never be self-inflicting any illness in the future. It’s just become so obvious, that’s your body telling you the harm you’ve done. It seems a bit reckless to keep repeating that. I’ve done everything in my power to keep healthy for my little boy’s sake ever since we planned creating him. Unfortunately at times there’s been very little I could do to combat some pretty major problems. If something good is going to come out of that, it’s that I’m not going to take for granted or abuse my health any more. Perhaps I should forego alcohol altogether, perhaps I will, but for now I can at least commit to hangovers being a thing of the past.

    • Neil Bennion 2 January 2013 at 11:19 am · Reply

      Thanks for the insight Christina!

  2. Angela 1 January 2013 at 10:10 pm · Reply

    Excellent post. thx. btw I think your site does a great job of promoting an alcohol-free lifestyle as a positive choice- which is the best way to change habits and behaviours. Cheers!

    • Neil Bennion 2 January 2013 at 10:09 am · Reply

      Thanks Angela!

  3. Simon 3 January 2013 at 9:43 pm · Reply

    Good read. I’ve had similar experiences of periods of abstinence (lent/”I’ll never drink again”), and can particularly relate to being bullied and made to feel that I should justify the choice. I always wonder whether if in doubt of one’s relationship with booze the question isn’t “should I give up for a bit?” but actually “should I give up?”.

    • Neil Bennion 4 January 2013 at 11:13 am · Reply

      It’s a good question. I think the jump from not having a drink during January to never having one again is a massive one. That said, people on a short stint seem to get more pressure – perhaps because they’re seen as ‘corruptible’.

  4. Cathy 4 January 2013 at 7:45 am · Reply

    Hi Neil, this is a really great article. Having a dry month is not a cure in itself. I can certainly identify with feeling pressure to be ‘bad’ and have an alcoholic drink. Because I have done this before I know how it can play out. The thing is though, I feel stronger having done this before, and I am motivated by the benefits (particularly consuming less calories) and saving money. I’d already limited my alcohol consumption to the weekend only, I feel that my approach to what I consume may change again after this month. Only time will tell.

    • Neil Bennion 4 January 2013 at 11:23 am · Reply

      Thanks Cathy, I think that the motivation you’re talking about really helps. In fact I know someone who is using that ‘MyDrinkAware’ web app (see link in article) which taps into that very aspect. All the best with it.

Leave a Comment

Read previous post:
Taste Test: Alcohol-free Christmas Puddings

If you’re anything like me – that is a slightly food-obsessed person living in the UK (please, don't call me...